Post Reply 
 
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
The bookcase Investigation guess list
18-04-2005, 06:42 PM
Post: #1
The bookcase Investigation guess list

Ok Folks the moment you have all been waiting for............

I'm going to make a start otherwise we'll be here all night.
Some peeps posted their reasons too which I'm going to add if they don't mind (tough if they do)

First up to guess was Survivor fan, and this is what he thought....

1 Flip
2 Flyo
3 Member*
4 Isis
5 Critique
6 Groucho
7 Bob
8 Cockney
9 Secrets
10 Andrea
11 Ceri
12 Marmoset
13 Mazwad
14 ILS
15 Buzz
16 Patsy
17 Cat
18 SF
19 Bella
20 Fee FA
21 Islandman
22 Red Herring

Next we have Mazwad's guesses

1 Fee For All
2 Critique
3 ILS
4 Cat
5 Red Herring
6 Survivor Fan
7 Ceridwen
8 Cockney
9 Bob
10 Isis
11 Mazwad
12 patsy
13 Bella
14 Andrea
15 Groucho
16 big knicks
17 Secrets
18 islandman
19 Marmoset
20 Buzz
21 Flip
22 Flyo

And Flip's with reasons!

1. Me

2. BUZZ - It was the Martina Cole - 'The graft' that gave me my clue.

3. GROUCHO - Bit of a guess, but a piccie of Mrs G, along with kids vids and the trophies - and the 2nd World War Book - sort of blokeish!

4. BELLA - it was Chocolat that gave the game away.

5. FLYO - I dunno with this one - it was the only one that looked sort of studenty, oh and the pint glass on the shelf along with the green [think Grolsch]

6. ANDREA - Well the weather/sky books were a of a giveawy, also the USA connection and the trilogy inc. The northern Lights, The Subtle Knife.

7. ISLANDMAN - The Paula Radcliffe Bio gave this away - I read that he was after it. Oh and there was a swimming book.

8. MAZWAD - this was a hard one and I am still not sure, but the books were girly and I couldn't think of anyone else.

9. SECRETS - far too many books - LOL - it just had to be him.

10. ISIS - the biggest giveaway was the Chill Out sign at the top, very isis. Also the Fishing books, hooked on Bass. And the Hollywood Divorces and Azur like it - the clincher was The enemy of God.

11. MARMOSET - another hard one, but there was a Manchester Utd connection - and Marmy got her new horse from somewhere in the middle of the country - I know very vague but it was the best I could do.

12. CERIDWEN - well it couldn't be anyone else. With Hot Sex, The Marquis De Sade - but it was the Karin Slaughter clue that gave this to me.

13. FEE - This was a bit of a guess, but I imagine Fee is quite well read and there were some heavyweights here.

14. ILS - it was the Disney characters that gave this one away.

15. SF - it had to be, fab floor btw - but the odd selection of books, just to put me off the scent - LOL!!

16. CAT - well who else would air their knickers in public?? No also cos Cat has already shown her bookshelf - and it made everyone laugh!

17. CRITIQUE - The Annual from 1958 sort of made me think of Critique, and the poem selection 'from firends' - I could imagine Mazwad buying her this.

18. COCKNEY - Oh I hope I am right on this one - but I think it was the Map book 1800 - 1855 and the Map of GT London - and cockney is a cockney - also a bloke type of shelf, bikes, cars DIY!

19. PATSY - the Karma Sutra??? Also the Guide to Toddlers.

20. BOB - it is you!! The York yellow pages made me think of you?

21. MEMBER WITH NO NAME - but I reckon it is Floopy - it is the Clangers that made me think of Floops! She likes them.

22. RED HERRING - and I note a NAtional Trust guide to Car Parks in the Lakes - so I think you took this as a red herring - you like Lakes and Mountains??


Andrea

1 - Fee
2 - Critique
3 - Buzz
4 - Secrets
5 - Mazwad
6 - Andrea
7 - Islandman
8 - Groucho
9 - Bob
10 - Isis
11 - red herring
12 - Ceri
13 - Survivorfan
14 - Ils
15 - Cockney
16 - Cat
17 - Flip
18 - Patsy
19 - Bella
20 - Marmoset
21 - Flyo
22 - red herring

ILS

1) Buzz
2) Flyo
3) Bella
4) Critique
5) Survivor Fan
6) Ceridwen
7) Cat
8) Bob
9) Member with no name
10) Isis
11) Andrea
12) Marmoset
13) Islandman
14) ILS
15) Groucho
16) Cockney
17) Secrets
18) Patsy
19) Mazwad
20) Red Herring
21) Flip
22) Fee For All

Marmoset

1 Mazwad
2 Patsy
3 Fee for All
4 Bella
5 Red Herring
6 Ceridwen
7 Flip
8 Patsy
9 Red herring
10 isis
11 Critique
12 Survivorfan
13 Islandman
14 Buzz
15 Marmoset
16 Cockney
17 Secrets
18 Groucho
19 Andrea
20 ILS
21 Bob
22 Flyo


Secrets


) Andrea = Bookcase number 14.
2) Bob = Bookcase number 20.
3) Bella = Bookcase number 9.
4) Buzz = Bookcase number 11.
5) Cat = Bookcase number 21.
6) Ceridwen = Bookcase number 12.
7) Cockney = Bookcase number 4.
8) Critique = Bookcase number 13.
9) Fee For All = Bookcase number 19.
10) Flip = Bookcase number 1.
11) Flyo = Bookcase number 22.
12) Groucho = Bookcase number 3.
13)Islandman = Bookcase number 6.
14 ILS = Bookcase number 5.
15) Isis = Bookcase number 10.
16) Marmoset = Bookcase number 15.
17) Mazwad = Bookcase number 18.
18) Patsy = Bookcase number 2.
19) Secrets = Bookcase number 17.
20) Survivor Fan = Bookcase number 7.
21)Member with no name = Bookcase number 8.
22)Red Herring = Bookcase number 16.


Cockney


1) Secrets

2) Fee For All

3) Bella

4) Isis

5) Andrea

6)Red Herring

7) Bob

8) Groucho

9)Member with no name*

10) Survivor Fan

11) Buzz

12) Ceridwen

13) Flip

14)ILS

15) Cat

16) Flyo

17) Mazwad

18) Patsy

19) Critique

20) Marmoset

21) Cockney
22)Islandman

Critique

1 = Bella
2 = Critique (got that one right anyway)
3 = Buzz
4 = Cat
5 = Red Herring
6 = Andrea
7 = Islandman
8 = Secrets
9 = Flip
10 = Isis
11 = Mazwad
12 = Ceri
13 = SurvivorFan
14 = Flyo
15 = Marmoset
16 = Cockney (just his type of humour - lol)
17 = Groucho
18 = Feeforall
19 = Bob (picked out with a pin i'm afraid)
20 = ILS
21 = Patsy
22 = No name


Cat


1 = Survivorfan.
2 = Marmoset. She often asks for help about computer problems.
3 = Flyo. Studenty type shelves, obviously in a small room where there is no place else for the tv. Also medals for Grolsch drinking.
4=Cat
5 = Member with no name as too ashamed to admit to that wall paper.
6 = Secrets. Book “Dirty Secrets of the Second World War” also had to be a member of an older age because of the cassettes. (or this could be Isis)
7 = Ils – bb & survivor books
8 = Buzz. Because I know she has a big box.
9 = Cockney – black driving gloves
10 = Andrea – Book on Fishing.
11 = Mazwad
12= Ceredwin
13= Red Herring14 = Bella. Cuddley toys
15 = Grouch – nice expensive floor – can imagine him rolling round with naked Chinese people on it.
16=Pat. Big Pants
17= Flip no shelves
18= Fee – book on carpets
19=Isis.
20 = Bob. Yellow pages of York
21= Islandman
22= Critique. So dusty.

Fee For All

1 Secrets Ian Rankin books mentioned on book thread
2 Buzz
3 Flip
4 Isis Mr Nice’s book
5 Ils
6 Islandman
7 Cat
8 Red herring Looks like same room as 16
9 Fee I took the photo
10 Andrea Red hair card, and Viz
11 Bella
12 Ceri
13 Critique
14 SF
15 Marmoset Horsey book
16 No name Looks like same room as 9
17 Mazwad
18 Bob
19 Cockney
20 Groucho
21 Patsy
22 Flyo

Islandman

1. ILS
2. Flyo
3. Cockney
4. Bella
5. Patsy
6. Survivor Fan
7. Islandman
8. Mazwad
9. Fee for All
10. Isis
11. Critique
12. Ceridwin
13. Buzz
14. Cat
15. Flip
16. Red Herring
17. Secrets
18. Bob
19. Groucho
20. Marmoset
21. Member w/ no name
22. Andrea

Last but not least Nox

1 Flip
2 Fly
3 Patsy
4 Cat
5 Red herring
6 Ceridwen
7 Island Man
8 Cockney
9 Fee for all
10 Isis
11 Buzz
12 SF (I know what you're thinking lol, but I can't feeling the tel dir location doesn't fit in with the rest of the subjects)
13 Bella
14 ILS
15 Marmoset
16 Red herring
17 Critique
18 Groucho
19 Andrea
20 Bob
21 Mazwad
22 Secrets


__________________
............................rest to follow, about to time out!

The winner says it may be difficult but it is possible; the loser says it may be possible but it is too difficult
:yahoo: He's here!
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:09 PM
Post: #2
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Is there going to be more or can we start slagging people off now?




(apart from Cockney that is..x)
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:12 PM
Post: #3
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Thats it, you can start!

I'm about to reveal the winner, if you haven't already worked it out

The winner says it may be difficult but it is possible; the loser says it may be possible but it is too difficult
:yahoo: He's here!
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:16 PM
Post: #4
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Go on...go on...it wasn't me tho was it?

I'm just chuffed that Cockney thought I had that floor.

Woo hooooo

Just about to go back and check and see what other shelves I was guessed as.


Good game bobski, well done.
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:29 PM
Post: #5
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Why did no-one think mine was Number 15? :mad2:

ils - you're a dead woman :laugh:

[SIZE=3]

[url="http://www.TickerFactory.com/"]
[/url]
[/SIZE]
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:31 PM
Post: #6
The bookcase Investigation guess list
This is the reveal!

1 Flip
2 Critique
3 Groucho
4 Cat
5 Flyo
6 Andrea
7 Islandman
8 Buzz
9 Fee For All
10 Isis
11 Mazwad
12 Ceridwen
13 Bob
14 ILS
15 Marmoset
16 big knicks
17 Secrets
18 SurvivorFan
19 Bella
20 Member*
21 Cockney
22 Patsy

I'm sure you've all worked out by now who the winner is.

[Image: queennox.jpg]

Well Done to NOX]
Gold to Nox
Nox scored 39% (8.5) which is clasified as a defer at uni, but it'll do here!

Silver to Flip

Runner up was Flip with 36% (8), soo close flippy, but Nox got 1/2 bonus on the red herring

Bronze
to Secrets and Critique
Both scored 7.5, Secrets picking up a bonus 1/2 for gussing a red herring and Critique having a 1/2 deducted for sending me Maz's pic

And this is how the rest did

Andrea =6
Cat = 4
Cockney = 2
Critique = 7.5
Fee For All = 4.5
Marmoset = 3
Maz =6
Islandman = 6.5
Ils = 4.5
Survivor fan = 4

The winner says it may be difficult but it is possible; the loser says it may be possible but it is too difficult
:yahoo: He's here!
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:36 PM
Post: #7
The bookcase Investigation guess list
To all those that thought number 20 was mine............. fooled you! :laugh:
Well done for spotting the York Yellow pages, it isn't mine though, although I own one just like it. it belongs to my next door neighbour as do most of the books. The conspiracy book should have give it away (plots, lies and cover ups), but no one picked up on that, along with Myths and legends :laugh:

The winner says it may be difficult but it is possible; the loser says it may be possible but it is too difficult
:yahoo: He's here!
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:40 PM
Post: #8
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Well done Nox!!!



Most of ya got mine right. I was hoping the array of books from the UK would throw you off, but no such luck. lol.

My real question is why two people thought mine was number 13...which has a book titled "Manners for Women" blatantly shown in the center of the picture. lmao.

And I must say I love Marmoset's bookcase...along with all the artwork and figures on top of it.
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:43 PM
Post: #9
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Well Done Nox
Quote this message in a reply
18-04-2005, 07:45 PM
Post: #10
The bookcase Investigation guess list
Islandman Wrote:My real question is why two people thought mine was number 13...which has a book titled "Manners for Women" blatantly shown in the center of the picture. lmao.

I didn't look at the books islandman - just put a name to a numbered bookcase! So it was just pot luck I gave you number 13! Sorry!
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  Guess what... PJ 23 1,746 13-06-2006 08:25 AM
Last Post: Coastie
  Have A Guess Seabreeze 31 2,285 09-03-2006 02:00 PM
Last Post: Seabreeze
  Guess your number... JakeyBoy 5 725 21-12-2005 03:17 PM
Last Post: msgirl
  The baby Investigation entries Bob 92 4,181 26-05-2005 08:43 AM
Last Post: Dolores
  The baby Investigation Bob 17 1,389 19-05-2005 06:50 PM
Last Post: Bob
  The next Investigation Bob 45 2,219 12-05-2005 01:53 AM
Last Post: secrets
  The bookcase investigation entries Bob 116 5,012 18-04-2005 06:46 PM
Last Post: Cat
  The bookcase question thread Andrea 13 1,998 15-04-2005 08:41 PM
Last Post: Marmoset
  The bookcase investigation. Bob 45 2,878 11-04-2005 07:16 PM
Last Post: Bob
  Ignore list claire 49 3,472 22-01-2005 01:33 PM
Last Post: ils

Forum Jump:


User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)